I recently responded to newsletter from the Raindance Film Festival claiming that "talent" was a myth.
Here's the original article:
http://www.raindance.org/site/debunking-the-talent-myth-6-ways
And here's my response:
Hi Elliott,
I appreciate receiving all of your Newsletters - they are always interesting and insightful. This time, however, I could not disagree with you more.
Merriam-Webster definition of "talent":
a: the natural endowments of a person; b: a special often athletic, creative, or artistic aptitude; general intelligence or mental power; ability
To say that everyone is born with equal talent is to say that everyone is born with equal intelligence - it just isn't true. Each person is born with a certain amount of talent/ability/intelligence and it is their own personal responsibility to build upon those natural gifts.
As a child I was given gifted tests in 2nd grade and 6th grade. It was determined that I was gifted in English, reading comprehension, visual memory/analysis, abstract problem-solving and sense of direction. I was not gifted in Math. My (much younger) cousin was gifted in Math. At 5 years old he could solve complex equations within seconds without the aid of a calculator. It was amazing. Could I do that? No. I didn't have that natural ability or talent. Could he draw like an adult, conceive an original story or comprehend Shakespeare? No. That was my talent. Could I learn to solve equations in my head like him some day? Maybe, but I doubt it. I have problems figuring out how much to tip at Denny's.
It's like saying that Steven Hawking and Jerry Rice were born with the same talents. Or that either one of them could direct a movie. It's fairly absurd.
The great thing about movies is that there are so many different aspects of filmmaking and therefore multiple jobs for various talents. Producers must be talented managers and organizers. Production accountants must have a talent for figures. Writers must be talented wordsmiths. Composers must be musically talented. Directors must be visually talented.
Even Brett Ratner admits that he's "not the most talented person" but he is one of the most driven. Will Brett Ratner ever be Stanley Kubrick? No. Never. He has lots of money, tools and talented people around him to help him make movies, but he wasn't born with Kubrick's talent.
I appreciate your attempt to encourage people who are insecure about their talent - it's very admirable - but it's a little misguided. I think your comment on passion is the most relavant. I think the message should really be: Don't worry so much about your talent - concentrate on your passion and you'll achieve great things.
Thanks for reading and I look forward to reading your next post!
All the Best,
-t. arthur cottam
www.misfitFILMS.com
www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Thursday, March 29, 2012
Is "Talent" A Myth?
Labels:
ability,
aptitude,
blog,
creativity,
misfit films,
movies,
Raindance,
talent
Monday, August 15, 2011
Ask Jenna Leigh: Penis Size
Does size really matter? Jenna Leigh answers the age-old question. www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Sunday, August 14, 2011
Ask Jenna Leigh: Virginity
Wondering how to keep your boyfriend satisfied while holding onto your precious cherry pie? Jenna Leigh has the answer!www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Ask Jenna Leigh: Sexual Harrassment
What should you do when you're being sexually harrassed by a pervy professor? Jenna Leigh has the answer!www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Monday, August 8, 2011
Ask Jenna Leigh: Mulatto Baby
How can you assure that your illegitimate mixed-race baby will be financially taken care of? Jenna Leigh has the answer! www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Friday, July 8, 2011
Ask Jenna Leigh: Sex Drive
Jenna Leigh shows you how to improve your doggy style. No animals were harmed in the making of this webisode...except for the cats. www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Friday, May 6, 2011
Ask Jenna Leigh: Cheating
What should you do if you're cheating and you get pregnant? Ask Jenna Leigh! www.DirtyLittleShorts.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)